Authentic Learning Task (ALT) #2: The Predictive Powers of Ice Cream

Printer-Friendly Version

Overview

This ALT introduces order in the Design of Experiments (DOE) process through regression and pre-selection of factors and levels to test. This ALT asks you to consider the independent variables identified as significant in a factorial design procedure, and use them to generate data to put into a regression procedure. The purpose of the regression equation is to predict values of the dependent variable from the significant independent variables.

In this ALT, the dependent variable to be observed is the time required to freeze ice cream for two levels of milk fat and two levels of rock salt added to ice in a plastic bag ice cream freezer. You use Excel to generate the prediction equation.

After completing this ALT, you should be able to demonstrate the following competencies:

  • Use sound sampling techniques and data analysis to make repeatable, defensible inferences (Comp. 1).
  • Solve real world problems be designing and conducting factorial and fractional factorial experiments (Comp. 2).
  • Graphically display outcomes using regression analysis to communicate the recommended action based on the experiment (Comp. 4).

Materials and Equipment
No materials or equipment are needed to complete this ALT.

Safety and Disposal
The milk products must be kept refrigerated until ready for use.

Pre-Activity

In this activity, the relationship between the dependent variable (freeze time) and the independent variables (rock salt and % fat in the milk) will be determined by the use of scatter diagrams and regression equations.

In order to prepare for this activity, complete the learning object on scatter
diagrams
and review the Carillontech.com instructions for creating scatter charts.


This graph provides an example of a scatter chart and best fit regression line for predicting the relationship between the use of two different instruments when measuring thirty different parts.

Self Assessment

For the following data, found in the attached file, compares the measurements of a chemical (x1– dependent variable) and a reagent (x2 – independent Variable) used to obtain the result by creating scatter chart and determining the regression line. The answers are available on the Solution sheet. Click here to access sample.

Additional Analysis – ANOVA (Analysis of Variance)

The Data Analysis Package in Excel has a regression subroutine that produces the equation for the line correlation coefficient and tests the “goodness” of the predictor line fit using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). The underlying principal is the allocation of variation to the “theoretical” and the unassigned variation which is typically called “error”. The Fisher test (F test) is used to determine if the “Null Hypothesis” that there is “No difference” between the variation predicted by the model when compared to the random or unassigned variation typically known as “error.” By rejecting the null hypothesis that the variation is the same between the predicted and error, we conclude that the model explains the difference.

An example problem comparing the measurements collected from two operators of the same thirty parts using both the approach developed in the first section using scatter plots and the regression equation is reworked using the Regression subroutine in the Data Analysis Package found in Excel. The problem is also reworked using a web based software package Statcrunch found at www.statcrunch.com.

What conclusion can you make concerning the operators? Are they consistent and are there any offsets (bias) in their measurements?

ANOVA is essential when we want to compare more than two variables i.e Is there a difference in quality among the three suppliers? Or five ?

To learn more about ANOVA, the following websites and simulators are helpful. (We will be revisiting this topic in a later activity.)

Utah State - www.psych.utah.edu/stat/introstats/anovaflash.html

Rice University - www.ruf.rice.edu/~lane/stat_sim/one_way/index.html

Click here for a glossary of terms.

Activity

In your team, perform the following steps to complete the activity:

  1. Complete tasks on Instruction Sheet: Shake, Shake, Shake.
  2. Record your time on your facilitator's copy of Facilitator Data Sheet: Participants' Freeze Time.
  3. Feed the data on Facilitator Data Sheet: Participants' Freeze Time into the Excel program to create a regression equation.
  4. Complete the remainder of Data Sheet: Freeze Time.

Post-Activity

Your team should now post its results from the activity to the Discussion Board.

Assignment
There are no instructions to prepare for ALT #3: Back to the Brewery

Assessment
Your facilitator may use Assessment Sheet: The Predictive Powers of Ice Cream to evaluate your results from the activity and your posting to the Discussion Board.

Go to next ALT

Statistical Experiments Home Page

 

..........................................................................